Dogtra 1900s VS. Garmin Sport Pro: The Ultimate Showdown

Dog lovers and trainers, you’re in for a treat today! When it comes to choosing the perfect training tool for your furry friend, it’s essential to find the right balance between functionality and ease of use. 

In this article, we’ll dive into the nitty-gritty of two popular training devices – the Dogtra 1900s and the Garmin Sport Pro. Both of these devices have their loyal fan base, but which one comes out on top? Let’s find out!

A Brief Comparison Table

FeatureDogtra 1900sGarmin Sport Pro
Stimulation Levels127 levels10 levels
RangeUp to 3/4 mileUp to 3/4 mile
ExpandableUp to 2 dogsUp to 3 dogs
WaterproofIPX9K ratingYes
Suitable for Small DogsFor dogs weighing 35 lbs and upFor dogs weighing as little as 10 lbs
One-Handed OperationNoYes
Built-In BarkLimiterNoYes
Battery Type2-hour rapid charge Lithium PolymerRechargeable lithium-ion
Battery Life50-70 hours (depending on usage)Up to 60 hours
WarrantyLimited lifetime warrantyOne-year warranty

Setting the Scene: Dogtra 1900s and Garmin Sport Pro

Before we jump into the pros and cons, let’s take a quick look at each device’s background.

The Dogtra 1900s

The Dogtra 1900s is an e-collar designed for professional dog trainers and serious pet owners alike. With a range of up to 3/4 mile, it’s perfect for off-leash training, obedience work, and even hunting. Its standout feature is its precise stimulation levels, which allow you to customize your training experience.

The Garmin Sport Pro

On the other hand, the Garmin Sport Pro is a compact, lightweight device that’s perfect for active pet owners. With its one-handed operation, built-in BarkLimiter, and simple design, it’s a versatile tool for training and controlling your dog in various situations.

Now that we’ve set the stage let’s dive into the pros and cons of each device.

Dogtra 1900s Pros and Cons

Dogtra 1900s
Dogtra 1900s


1. Precise Stimulation Levels

The Dogtra 1900s offers a whopping 127 stimulation levels, allowing you to fine-tune the intensity to suit your dog’s temperament and training needs. This precision ensures a tailored training experience that’s gentle yet effective.

2. Waterproof and Durable

With its IPX9K waterproof rating, the Dogtra 1900s is built to withstand the elements. Whether you’re training in the rain or near water, you can rest assured that the device will continue to function flawlessly.

3. Long-Range Capability

With a range of up to 3/4 mile, the Dogtra 1900s is perfect for off-leash training or hunting in open fields. This extended range ensures you maintain control over your dog, even in challenging environments.


1. Steeper Learning Curve

The Dogtra 1900s’ multiple stimulation levels and features can be a bit overwhelming for new users. It may take some time to get comfortable with the device and fully utilize its potential.

2. Higher Price Point

The Dogtra 1900s tends to be more expensive than the Garmin Sport Pro, which may be a deterrent for some pet owners.

Garmin Sport Pro Pros and Cons

Garmin Sport Pro


1. One-Handed Operation

The Garmin Sport Pro is designed for one-handed use, with easily accessible buttons and a compact design. This feature allows you to keep your focus on your dog, making training sessions more efficient and enjoyable.

2. Built-In BarkLimiter

This unique feature helps control your dog’s barking by detecting and correcting excessive barking automatically. The BarkLimiter ensures your dog remains well-behaved, even when you’re not actively training.

3. Lower Price Point

The Garmin Sport Pro is typically more affordable than the Dogtra 1900s, making it an attractive option for pet owners on a budget.


1. Limited Stimulation Levels

The Garmin Sport Pro offers ten stimulation levels, which may not provide enough precision for some dog trainers or pet owners. This limitation can make it challenging to find the ideal intensity for your dog’s training needs.

2. Shorter Range

With a range of up to 3/4 mile, the Garmin Sport Pro falls short of the Dogtra 1900s’ impressive range. While this range is sufficient for most training situations, it may not be ideal for off-leash training or hunting in more expansive environments.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. Can I use the Dogtra 1900s and Garmin Sport Pro for multiple dogs?

Yes, both devices allow you to expand their functionality to train multiple dogs simultaneously. The Dogtra 1900s is expandable up to two dogs, while the Garmin Sport Pro can be expanded to train up to three dogs.

2. Are these devices suitable for small dogs?

The Dogtra 1900s is designed for dogs weighing 35 pounds and up, whereas the Garmin Sport Pro is suitable for dogs weighing as little as 10 pounds. If you have a small dog, the Garmin Sport Pro may be a better option.

3. Are these devices safe to use on my dog?

Both the Dogtra 1900s and the Garmin Sport Pro are designed with safety in mind. The stimulation levels are adjustable to ensure a gentle yet effective training experience. It’s essential to follow the manufacturer’s guidelines and consult with a professional dog trainer if you’re unsure about using these devices.

4. How long do the batteries last on these devices?

The Dogtra 1900s features a 2-hour rapid charge Lithium Polymer battery, which can last between 50-70 hours, depending on usage. The Garmin Sport Pro has a rechargeable lithium-ion battery with a runtime of up to 60 hours.

5. Can I use these devices for obedience training as well as hunting?

Yes, both the Dogtra 1900s and the Garmin Sport Pro are versatile enough to be used for obedience training, off-leash training, and hunting. Their range and features make them suitable for various training situations and environments.

6. Do these devices come with warranties?

Both the Dogtra 1900s and the Garmin Sport Pro come with warranties, providing peace of mind when purchasing. The Dogtra 1900s has a limited lifetime warranty, while the Garmin Sport Pro comes with a one-year warranty. It’s essential to register your device and follow the manufacturer’s guidelines to maintain warranty coverage.

The Verdict: Which Device Should You Choose?

Ultimately, the choice between the Dogtra 1900s and the Garmin Sport Pro depends on your specific needs, preferences, and budget. If you’re looking for a highly customizable device with a wide range of stimulation levels and a longer range, the Dogtra 1900s is the way to go. On the other hand, if you prefer a more straightforward, user-friendly device with one-handed operation and a built-in BarkLimiter, the Garmin Sport Pro is an excellent choice.

Clayton S. Johnson

Well, I am Clayton who writes, manages, and does overall stuff for this website. I live somewhere in Stone Mountain, Georgia, and used to have a full-time job. But the pandemic taught me to do more do with my life. So, I quit my job and travel a lot! Since I have tons of time now, I write about all the stuff I have done, used, and have first-hand experiences.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.