Rainier VS. Phantom Screens: A Battle Of Retractable Screens

There’s no better feeling than having a screen door that retracts, revealing a beautiful outdoor view and welcoming fresh air into your home. In the world of retractable screens, two brands stand out: Rainier and Phantom. 

Both have their pros and cons, which we’ll explore in this article. Let’s dive into the world of retractable screens and discover which option is perfect for your home.

A Brief Comparison Table 

FeatureRainier ScreensPhantom Screens
DurabilityHigh-quality materials, powder-coated finishKnown for quality and durability
InstallationEasy installation with clear instructionsMore challenging installation
CustomizationExtensive customization optionsLimited customization options
PriceGenerally more expensiveRange of options for various budgets
AvailabilityLimited availability, fewer dealersWidely available, numerous dealers
AestheticsCustomizable to match home’s styleSleek, minimal design
WarrantyVaries by dealer, inquire for specificsLimited lifetime warranty
Product RangeNot as diverse as PhantomWide range of products for various needs
Mesh Material OptionsVarious mesh types availableFiberglass, solar mesh, pet-resistant
UV ResistanceDepends on mesh material choiceMesh materials with UV-resistant coatings

The Story of Rainier Screens

Rainier screens, manufactured by Rainier Industries, have been around for quite some time. This company has built a solid reputation in the industry, earning the trust of thousands of homeowners. But what makes Rainier screens so special?

Pros of Rainier Screens

Rainier Screens
Rainier Screens


Rainier screens are known for their durability. They’re built with high-quality materials, designed to withstand everyday wear and tear. The aluminum housing and powder-coated finish provide an extra layer of protection, ensuring your screen lasts for years to come.

Easy Installation

Installing a Rainier screen is relatively simple, even for those who aren’t DIY experts. The brand provides clear instructions and all necessary hardware, making the process a breeze.


Rainier screens can be customized to fit your home’s unique aesthetic. Choose from various colors, mesh types, and even motorized options, allowing you to create a screen that matches your home’s style.

Cons of Rainier Screens


Rainier screens can be on the expensive side. While their durability and customization options may justify the cost for some, budget-conscious homeowners may be turned off by the price tag.

Limited Availability

Rainier screens are not as widely available as Phantom screens. You may need to do some extra legwork to find a dealer that carries Rainier products in your area.

The Tale of Phantom Screens

Phantom Screens
Phantom Screens

Phantom Screens, on the other hand, is a well-known brand that has been in the retractable screen business for over 25 years. Known for their innovative designs and commitment to quality, Phantom Screens has become a household name.

Pros of Phantom Screens

Wide Range of Products

Phantom Screens offers a diverse product line, with options to suit various needs and budgets. From door screens to window screens, and even large openings, Phantom has a solution for every homeowner.

Aesthetic Appeal

Phantom Screens are designed with aesthetics in mind. The sleek, minimal design complements a wide range of architectural styles, ensuring your screen blends seamlessly with your home’s appearance.


Phantom Screens stands by their products, offering a limited lifetime warranty on all screens. This gives homeowners peace of mind, knowing that their investment is protected.

Cons of Phantom Screens

Installation Complexity

Phantom screens can be more challenging to install than Rainier screens. While they provide instructions, homeowners who aren’t handy may need to hire a professional, adding to the overall cost.

Limited Customization

Phantom Screens doesn’t offer as many customization options as Rainier. While they do have a variety of colors and mesh types, their selection isn’t as extensive.

FAQ Section

Are phantom screens any good?

Phantom screens are known for their quality and durability. They offer a wide range of products to suit various needs and budgets. Many homeowners are satisfied with their Phantom Screens and enjoy the aesthetic appeal they add to their homes.

How much are phantom retractable screens?

The cost of Phantom retractable screens can vary depending on the size, type, and additional features. In general, prices can range from $200 to over $1,000. It’s essential to get a quote from a local dealer for accurate pricing.

How durable is a phantom screen?

Phantom screens are built with quality materials designed to withstand regular use and various weather conditions. They also offer a limited lifetime warranty, giving homeowners confidence in their durability. However, as with any product, proper care and maintenance are essential to ensure longevity.

What are phantom screens made of?

Phantom screens are made using a combination of high-quality materials, including extruded aluminum for the frame and various mesh materials for the screen itself. The mesh options include fiberglass, solar mesh, and even pet-resistant screens to suit different needs and preferences.

What is the strongest screen?

The strongest screen material is typically a stainless steel or bronze screen. These materials offer superior strength and durability compared to traditional fiberglass or aluminum screens. However, they may not be suitable for all applications, as they can be more expensive and may not offer the same level of visibility.

What is the longest lasting screen?

The longest lasting screen material is likely a combination of durability, resistance to UV damage, and proper maintenance. Stainless steel or bronze screens offer excellent durability, while screens treated with UV-resistant coatings can help prevent sun damage. Regular cleaning and maintenance will also ensure your screen lasts as long as possible.

The Verdict: Rainier or Phantom?

Both Rainier and Phantom screens have their own unique advantages and drawbacks. Ultimately, the choice comes down to your specific needs, preferences, and budget.

If you prioritize customization and easy installation, Rainier screens might be the better option for you. However, if you’re looking for a more widely available product with a diverse range of options and a strong warranty, Phantom screens could be the winner.

Before making a decision, it’s essential to do your research, compare products, and consider consulting with a local dealer who can provide valuable insight and advice. Regardless of which brand you choose, a retractable screen can enhance your home’s comfort, functionality, and curb appeal for years to come.

Clayton S. Johnson

Well, I am Clayton who writes, manages, and does overall stuff for this website. I live somewhere in Stone Mountain, Georgia, and used to have a full-time job. But the pandemic taught me to do more do with my life. So, I quit my job and travel a lot! Since I have tons of time now, I write about all the stuff I have done, used, and have first-hand experiences.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.