If you’re someone who enjoys the art of crafting a classic Old Fashioned, or you’re just starting to appreciate this timeless cocktail, the Mixologer Old Fashioned Box is something you absolutely need to try.
Whether you’re a whiskey aficionado or someone who loves a good gift box that allows you to indulge in high-quality spirits, this box offers an experience like no other.
Featuring hand-selected craft spirits, syrups, and the necessary garnishes, it brings the cocktail experience to your home. It’s the perfect way to elevate your at-home bar while exploring unique flavors that will change the way you enjoy an Old Fashioned.
The Mixologer Old Fashioned Box includes everything you need for making a variety of Old Fashioned cocktails, and more. If you’re looking for a gift for a cocktail lover or want to treat yourself to something truly special, this box is a great choice.
After trying it myself, I can honestly say that it has become a regular part of my bar setup, and it’s one of the best ways to experiment with and perfect your Old Fashioned recipe. Let me take you through my experience with this box and why I believe it’s a must-have for any Old Fashioned enthusiast.
Why Should You Buy It?

As someone who enjoys experimenting with cocktails, I found this box to be a complete game-changer. It’s more than just a box of ingredients; it’s an opportunity to refine your bartending skills and develop a deeper appreciation for the
Old Fashioned cocktail. The curated selection of craft spirits is a standout feature. You’ll get to sample some premium whiskies and spirits that you likely wouldn’t find at your local liquor store. This is an opportunity to enjoy high-end liquor without having to commit to an entire bottle.
If you’re like me, you’ll appreciate how easy it is to recreate a classic Old Fashioned with all the right ingredients. Plus, the quality of the bitters and syrup included with the box makes each cocktail taste like it was crafted by a professional bartender.
Bonus: The included garnishes—organic orange slices and maraschino cherries—are the cherry on top, literally. These fresh elements complete the drink, ensuring it looks as good as it tastes.
Whether you’re a novice or a seasoned Old Fashioned drinker, this box is a fantastic way to try new things and elevate your cocktail game.
What’s Inside the Box? A Quick Look
Each Mixologer Old Fashioned Box is thoughtfully curated to provide an exceptional cocktail experience. The box includes:
- Eight unique craft spirits: Carefully chosen by expert mixologists, these spirits bring out the best in any Old Fashioned variation.
- Eight servings of demerara syrup: This rich, flavorful syrup complements the whiskey perfectly, enhancing the sweetness without overwhelming the drink.
- Bitters: A crucial ingredient that adds depth and complexity, making your Old Fashioned truly unique.
- Organic orange slices and maraschino cherries: These garnishes aren’t just for show—they add a refreshing citrus note and a subtle sweetness that takes the drink to another level.
What stands out immediately is the quality of the ingredients. The selection of spirits is exceptional—each one is distinct, offering a different flavor profile that allows you to explore new variations of the Old Fashioned.
How to Get the Most Out of the Mixologer Old Fashioned Box?

To make sure you’re getting the most from your Mixologer Old Fashioned Box, there are a few tips I recommend based on my personal experience:
- Experiment with Different Spirits: Don’t stick to just one type of whiskey. Use the different craft spirits to create unique Old Fashioned variations. You might be surprised at how different each one tastes.
- Use the Right Tools: The box comes with cocktail picks, but if you want to make your drinks extra special, try using a metal muddler or a mixing spoon to give your cocktails a professional touch.
- Perfect the Garnish: Don’t just throw in the garnishes haphazardly—make sure to give the orange peel a twist to release its oils. This adds extra aroma and flavor, elevating your Old Fashioned.
- Try It Over Ice or Neat: Depending on your taste, experiment with the Old Fashioned on the rocks or neat. I found that trying it both ways helped me discover the best way to enjoy the drink.
Pros & Cons of the Mixologer Old Fashioned Box

Pros:
- Premium Selection of Spirits: The spirits included in the box are top-notch. They’re hand-selected by experts to enhance your Old Fashioned experience, which means you get to explore high-quality, craft liquors that are hard to find in stores.
- Perfect for Experimenting: The variety of spirits lets you mix and match, creating different variations of the Old Fashioned to suit your taste. This is perfect for those who love experimenting with new flavors.
- Complete Cocktail Kit: The box includes everything you need—bitters, syrup, spirits, garnishes, and cocktail picks—so you don’t have to worry about sourcing ingredients individually.
- Great Gift Idea: If you’re looking for a gift for a cocktail lover, this is a winner. The presentation and variety make it a thoughtful and impressive gift.
- High-Quality Garnishes: The organic orange slices and maraschino cherries are a nice touch. You don’t get this level of quality with most Old Fashioned kits.
Cons:
- Limited Availability: The spirits included in the box are unique, but they might not be easily accessible if you’re looking for a refill once you’ve gone through everything in the box. You may need to hunt for similar ingredients.
- Price: While the box is filled with high-quality items, the cost might be a bit steep for some, especially if you’re not a frequent Old Fashioned drinker.
- Not Ideal for Beginners: While it’s perfect for Old Fashioned aficionados, beginners might find it overwhelming. You’ll need some basic knowledge of cocktails to fully appreciate the variety of spirits included in the box.
By following these tips, you can truly get the most out of your Mixologer Old Fashioned Box, crafting perfect cocktails every time.
Also Read: My Experience With Pocas Bubble Tea
Mixologer Vs. Other Old Fashioned Kits
Mixologer’s Old Fashioned Box stands out for a few reasons, and it’s helpful to compare it to other brands to see how it measures up:
- Mixologer Vs. The Cocktail Box
While both offer a curated selection of ingredients for Old Fashioned cocktails, Mixologer’s box includes a wider range of craft spirits, giving you more variety to experiment with. The Cocktail Box, on the other hand, tends to focus more on the syrup and bitters, which makes Mixologer’s box a more comprehensive experience.
- Mixologer Vs. The Old Fashioned Kit by Makers Mark
The Makers Mark kit is a classic choice, but it focuses only on one type of whiskey—Makers Mark bourbon. Mixologer offers a variety of spirits, which is a big plus for those who want to explore different flavor profiles.
- Mixologer Vs. Drinkworks Old Fashioned
Drinkworks offers a machine-based approach to making cocktails, while Mixologer focuses on the hands-on experience. If you want a more authentic, craft cocktail experience, Mixologer’s box is the better choice.
- Mixologer Vs. Shaker & Spoon
Shaker & Spoon’s boxes are known for their quality and selection of cocktail ingredients. However, Mixologer’s Old Fashioned Box focuses exclusively on the Old Fashioned, offering a more in-depth exploration of this classic drink.
Also Read: My Thoughts On Why Is Barefoot Wine So Cheap
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Yes, the Old Fashioned is typically considered a strong cocktail. It’s made with whiskey (or bourbon), which is a high-proof spirit, and it’s usually not diluted with much other than a bit of bitters, syrup, and a splash of water. The result is a bold, flavorful drink that packs a punch.
To order an Old Fashioned like a pro, simply ask for an Old Fashioned made with your preferred whiskey or bourbon. If you have a favorite type of whiskey, don’t be shy to specify it. You can also request specific bitters or a particular type of syrup if the bar offers a variety.
While you can’t technically buy a pre-made bottle of Old Fashioned, many companies now offer ready-to-drink Old Fashioned cocktails in bottles or cans. However, for the best experience, it’s recommended to make your own from scratch using a cocktail kit like Mixologer’s.
The Old Fashioned is a favorite because of its simplicity, bold flavor, and versatility. It’s a cocktail that has stood the test of time, offering a smooth and rich taste with just the right balance of sweetness, bitterness, and alcohol. It’s perfect for sipping and provides a unique experience every time you make it, especially with a premium selection of spirits like those in the Mixologer Old Fashioned Box.
Final Thoughts
If you’re an Old Fashioned enthusiast or just getting started on your cocktail journey, the Mixologer Old Fashioned Box is the perfect addition to your home bar. Its unique selection of spirits, high-quality ingredients, and easy-to-use setup allow you to enjoy this classic cocktail in a whole new way. Whether for yourself or as a gift, this box makes every Old Fashioned you craft an exciting new experience. The Mixologer Old Fashioned Box is an investment that will enhance your cocktail-making skills and provide you with countless delicious drinks for years to come.