Mathews Brothers Windows Vs. Andersen Windows: The Battle Of Fenestration

When it comes to replacing your old, drafty windows, the decision often comes down to two renowned titans of the industry: Mathews Brothers Windows and Andersen Windows. These companies, each with a storied history of quality craftsmanship and innovation, have been the trusted choice for homeowners and builders for many decades. 

In this comprehensive article, we’ll delve into the comparison of Mathews Brothers Windows and Andersen Windows, giving you an insightful perspective on their unique advantages and potential drawbacks.

A Brief Comparison Table

Mathews Brothers WindowsAndersen Windows
OriginBelfast, Maine, 1854Minnesota, 1903
CustomizationExtensive optionsWide variety of styles
Energy EfficiencyEquipped with IGUsOften exceed ENERGY STAR® guidelines
DurabilityPremium materials and craftsmanshipQuality materials
WarrantyAvailable but some reported claim issuesComprehensive, but some reported customer service issues
PriceCan be higher due to customization and craftsmanshipOften higher due to variety and quality
After-Sales ServiceRobust customer serviceRobust customer service with occasional reported issues
Mathews Brothers Windows
Mathews Brothers Windows

Mathews Brothers Windows: The Craftsmen of Clarity

Born from the ingenious minds in Belfast, Maine in 1854, Mathews Brothers Windows prides itself on a rich tradition of producing high-quality, handcrafted windows. 

Using state-of-the-art technology merged with timeless craftsmanship, Mathews offers an array of windows that bring both beauty and efficiency to homes.

Pros of Mathews Brothers Windows

Customization is at the forefront of Mathews Brothers’ appeal. They offer an extensive range of styles, sizes, and finishes, allowing homeowners to tailor windows to their unique tastes and home design.

Energy efficiency also stands out in Mathews Brothers Windows. Their models come equipped with insulating glass units (IGUs) that deliver superior thermal performance, thereby reducing heating and cooling costs.

Durability and reliability are key features of Mathews Brothers Windows. With their windows manufactured using a combination of premium materials and meticulous craftsmanship, you’re assured of a product that will stand the test of time.

Cons of Mathews Brothers Windows

Despite their many advantages, Mathews Brothers Windows are not without potential downsides. Price, for instance, may be a sticking point. Their emphasis on customization and quality craftsmanship can lead to higher costs compared to some other window brands.

Moreover, while Mathews Brothers Windows does offer warranty coverage, some customers have reported difficulties with claim procedures, something to bear in mind when considering these windows.

Read More: About Naturally Aged Flooring

Andersen Windows: The Vanguard of Variety

Andersen Windows
Andersen Windows

Rooted in Minnesota since 1903, Andersen Windows has built a solid reputation as a leading manufacturer of windows that combine style, durability, and energy efficiency.

Pros of Andersen Windows

What sets Andersen Windows apart is their broad range of options. With a plethora of styles, materials, and finishes available, Andersen ensures homeowners can find the perfect window for their needs and design preferences.

Another advantage lies in Andersen’s commitment to energy efficiency. Their windows often meet or exceed ENERGY STAR® guidelines, translating to lower utility bills and a smaller environmental footprint.

Andersen also offers a robust warranty, assuring customers of long-term protection for their investment. This helps create peace of mind in the knowledge that Andersen stands behind the quality of its windows.

Cons of Andersen Windows

While Andersen Windows are highly regarded, they too have their cons. Similar to Mathews Brothers, cost is a significant factor. Andersen’s broad selection and quality materials often come with a higher price tag.

Additionally, despite the robust warranty, some homeowners have reported challenges in customer service, which could potentially affect the overall experience of owning Andersen Windows.

Read More: About Dakota Closet System

The Final Verdict: Mathews Brothers Windows vs Andersen Windows

While both Mathews Brothers Windows and Andersen Windows offer impressive quality, the decision ultimately boils down to personal preference. Consider factors such as budget, style preference, and customer service experiences when deciding.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

What are the energy efficiency ratings of Mathews Brothers Windows and Andersen Windows? 

Both manufacturers’ windows typically meet or exceed ENERGY STAR® requirements, although specific ratings may vary depending on the model.

Do Mathews Brothers and Andersen offer installation services? 

Yes, both companies offer professional installation services to ensure a proper fit and optimal performance of their windows.

Can I customize my Mathews Brothers or Andersen Windows? 

Absolutely! Both brands offer a variety of styles, sizes, and finishes for customization.

Are Mathews Brothers and Andersen Windows suitable for all climates? 

Yes. The windows from both manufacturers are designed to withstand various weather conditions. However, some specific models might perform better in certain climates.

Do both companies offer after-sales service? 

Yes, both Mathews Brothers and Andersen have robust customer service teams to handle any post-sale queries or concerns.

How do the warranties of Mathews Brothers and Andersen Windows compare? 

Both companies provide comprehensive warranties, but the specifics may vary. It’s important to review the warranty details for each brand before making a purchase.

Wrapping Things Up

In conclusion, both Mathews Brothers Windows and Andersen Windows bring their unique strengths to the table. While Mathews Brothers excels in customization and traditional craftsmanship, Andersen stands out with its wide variety and commitment to energy efficiency. 

Neither choice would lead you astray; instead, they promise to offer windows that not only elevate the aesthetic appeal of your home but also improve its energy efficiency. We hope this comparison has offered some clarity in your decision-making process, and may your new windows open to joy and serenity!

Clayton S. Johnson

Well, I am Clayton who writes, manages, and does overall stuff for this website. I live somewhere in Stone Mountain, Georgia, and used to have a full-time job. But the pandemic taught me to do more do with my life. So, I quit my job and travel a lot! Since I have tons of time now, I write about all the stuff I have done, used, and have first-hand experiences.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.