Jonathan Dirt Alternatives: Are They Any Good?

If you’re anything like me, you understand that the secret to great hair isn’t just genetics, it’s also the products you use. One product that has received rave reviews over the years is Jonathan Dirt Texturizing Paste.

It’s loved for its capacity to give hair that desirable ‘second-day’ texture and a flexible hold.

But, what if you’re looking for something a bit different? Maybe your hair reacts differently, or perhaps you’re just curious to explore other options?

Well, that’s where alternatives to Jonathan Dirt Texturizing Paste come in. Let’s dive into these options, shall we?

Alternatives To Jonathan Dirt Texturizing Paste

  • R+Co Badlands Dry Shampoo Paste: An Unconventional But Effective Pick
R+Co Badlands Dry Shampoo Paste

First on our list is the R+Co Badlands Dry Shampoo Paste.

Now, don’t let the term ‘dry shampoo’ confuse you.

This product is a master at texturizing and holds its own as a hair paste.

Its unique hybrid formula balances the cleansing properties of dry shampoo with the styling grip of a texturizing paste.

You get the best of both worlds – fresh and texturized hair. Perfect for all those who are always on the go.

Also Read: Alternatives To Master Krew Comb.

  • Aveda Control Paste: A Natural and Cruelty-Free Alternative

For those looking for a cruelty-free and more natural alternative to Jonathan Dirt, look no further than Aveda Control Paste.

It offers a pliable hold, and its flax seed-based formula leaves hair with a matte finish. Aveda’s dedication to sourcing natural ingredients will make your eco-friendly heart flutter.

  • American Crew Fiber: For A Strong, Yet Pliable Hold
American Crew Fiber

If a strong yet flexible hold is your ultimate goal, American Crew Fiber is an option worth exploring.

This product is perfect for adding volume to your hair while providing a strong, yet flexible hold.

It leaves you with a matte finish, which is excellent for those who prefer a less shiny look.

  • Sexy Hair’s Style Sexy Hair Frenzy: For the Rock Stars Among Us

For those who are looking to add an edge to their look, Style Sexy Hair Frenzy by Sexy Hair is a brilliant option. This paste is perfect for creating ‘frenzied’ and edgy styles with a matte finish.

Its strong hold and bulking agents provide thickness and volume, just the right attributes for the rock star in you.

  • Hanz de Fuko’s Claymation: The Luxury Pick

Last but not least, we have Hanz de Fuko’s Claymation, a hybrid hair product that merges wax and clay. Its high hold and matte finish have garnered it a dedicated fanbase. This luxury pick delivers all day resilience for those complicated hairstyles you love.

Further Competitors To Jonathan Dirt Texturizing Paste

Let’s continue our journey by exploring more worthy competitors to Jonathan Dirt Texturizing Paste. The world of hair styling products is vast, and with the constant innovation in the field, there are more options available than ever before.

  • TIGI Bed Head Manipulator: The Funky Alternative

An alternative that is hard to miss in its distinctive packaging is TIGI’s Bed Head Manipulator. This funky product is an all-rounder. It adds body, texture, and holds to any hair type, making it a versatile addition to your hair product collection.

  • Bumble and Bumble Sumotech: A Lightweight Lo-Gloss Option

If you’re looking for a lightweight, flexible option, Bumble and Bumble Sumotech is an excellent alternative. This product is a unique blend of a wax, paste, and creme all in one. It promises a low gloss and pliable hold that can easily be restyled throughout the day.

  • Oribe Rough Luxury Molding Wax: A High-End Competitor
Oribe Rough Luxury Molding Wax

As the name suggests, Oribe Rough Luxury Molding Wax is a premium product.

This molding wax delivers a strong hold with a semi-matte finish.

Oribe is renowned for their high-quality products, and this one is no exception.

The luxury experience is further enhanced by the product’s sophisticated scent.

  • Layrite Natural Matte Cream: A Budget-Friendly Pick

For those looking for a more budget-friendly alternative, Layrite Natural Matte Cream is a fantastic choice. Despite its affordable price, Layrite doesn’t compromise on quality. It delivers a medium hold and a natural, matte finish. Plus, it’s water-soluble, so it washes out easily.

  • Malin+Goetz Hair Pomade: A Plant-Based Alternative

Lastly, for those who prefer plant-based products, Malin+Goetz Hair Pomade is a perfect choice. It offers a firm hold, shine finish, and is packed with natural ingredients that nourish your hair. It’s also free from parabens and synthetic fragrances, making it a clean beauty favorite.

Also Read: How Come SEV Laser So Cheap?

Comparing Alternatives To Jonathan Dirt Texturizing Paste

Each alternative brings something unique to the table. The R+Co Badlands is an excellent option for those always on the move who value fresh and texturized hair.

Aveda Control Paste, on the other hand, appeals to the eco-friendly user with its cruelty-free, natural formula.

American Crew Fiber is perfect for anyone seeking a strong yet pliable hold, while the Style Sexy Hair Frenzy is a great fit for those seeking to add an edgy, rock star vibe to their look.

Lastly, Hanz de Fuko’s Claymation offers a luxurious experience, delivering high hold and matte finish for those intricate hairstyles.


While Jonathan Dirt Texturizing Paste has been a staple in many hair care routines, exploring alternatives can be an exciting journey. The alternatives we’ve discussed offer a range of benefits, from dual functionality to eco-friendly formulas.

No matter what your hair goals are, there’s an alternative to Jonathan Dirt that will match your specific needs.

Remember, the best way to discover the perfect product for your hair is to try different options and see what works best for you. Here’s to finding that perfect match that elevates your hair game to new heights!

Clayton S. Johnson

Well, I am Clayton who writes, manages, and does overall stuff for this website. I live somewhere in Stone Mountain, Georgia, and used to have a full-time job. But the pandemic taught me to do more do with my life. So, I quit my job and travel a lot! Since I have tons of time now, I write about all the stuff I have done, used, and have first-hand experiences.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.