Brooklinen Vs. LL Bean Sheets: A Cozy Confrontation

Welcome to the world of luxury sheets, where comfort and quality are top priorities. Today, we’ll delve into the ultimate showdown between Brooklinen and L.L. Bean, two of the most popular sheet brands on the market. 

We’ll discuss the pros and cons of each, answering all your burning questions to help you make an informed decision. So grab a cup of tea, sit back, and let’s talk about sheets!

A Brief History of Brooklinen and L.L. Bean

Brooklinen, founded in 2014 by husband and wife duo Vicki and Rich Fulop, quickly rose to fame with their direct-to-consumer business model. 

Offering luxury bedding at an affordable price, they’ve grown exponentially, winning over the hearts of sleep enthusiasts everywhere.

L.L. Bean, on the other hand, has been around for over a century. Founded by Leon Leonwood Bean in 1912, the company started as an outdoor gear retailer. 

Over time, they expanded into home goods, including their now-famous sheets, known for their quality and durability.

A Brief Comparison Table

FeatureBrooklinenL.L. Bean
MaterialsPercale, Sateen, Linen, TwillPercale, Flannel, Supima Cotton
Thread Count Range270 – 480280 – 400
Price Range$$$$$
Variety (colors/patterns)HighModerate
SoftnessVery GoodVery Good
BreathabilityVery GoodVery Good
Wrinkle ResistanceModerate (depends on material)Good
Trial Period365 daysNone
Customer ServiceGoodExcellent

In this comparison table, we break down the key differences between Brooklinen and L.L. Bean sheets across various features, providing you with a clear overview of what each brand brings to the table.


Brooklinen offers a wider range of materials, including percale, sateen, linen, and twill. In contrast, L.L. Bean primarily focuses on percale, flannel, and Supima cotton sheets.

Thread Count Range

Brooklinen sheets come in thread counts ranging from 270 to 480, while L.L. Bean’s thread count varies between 280 and 400. A higher thread count typically indicates a denser, smoother fabric.

Price Range

Brooklinen sheets generally fall within a more affordable price range ($$) compared to L.L. Bean sheets, which tend to be slightly more expensive ($$$).

Variety (colors/patterns)

Brooklinen boasts a more extensive selection of colors and patterns, allowing customers to find the perfect match for their bedroom decor. L.L. Bean offers a moderate variety in comparison.


L.L. Bean sheets are known for their excellent durability and long-lasting quality. While Brooklinen sheets are also durable, they may not last quite as long as their L.L. Bean counterparts.


Both Brooklinen and L.L. Bean sheets receive high marks for their softness, providing users with a comfortable and cozy sleeping experience.


Sheets from both brands offer very good breathability, ensuring that you stay cool during warm nights and cozy during cooler ones.

Wrinkle Resistance

L.L. Bean sheets generally have better wrinkle resistance than Brooklinen sheets, which may require ironing or steaming, particularly in the case of their percale and linen options.

Trial Period

Brooklinen stands out by offering a generous 365-day trial period for their sheets, giving customers plenty of time to decide if they’re satisfied with their purchase. L.L. Bean does not offer a trial period for their sheets.


Brooklinen provides a lifetime warranty on their sheets, showcasing their commitment to customer satisfaction. L.L. Bean does not offer a warranty for their sheets.

Customer Service

While Brooklinen has good customer service, L.L. Bean is known for its excellent customer support, promptly addressing and resolving any issues that may arise.

By understanding these key differences, you can make a more informed decision about which brand best suits your needs and preferences. Keep in mind that individual priorities and personal tastes vary, so the “best” choice will depend on what you value most in a set of sheets.

The Pros and Cons: Brooklinen Sheets

Brooklinen Sheet


  1. Variety

Brooklinen offers a wide range of sheet materials, including percale, sateen, linen, and twill. With various patterns and colors to choose from, you’re sure to find the perfect match for your bedroom aesthetic.

  1. Quality

Crafted from 100% long-staple cotton, Brooklinen sheets provide a soft, smooth, and durable sleeping experience.

  1. Affordability

Despite their high-quality materials, Brooklinen sheets are reasonably priced, offering luxury without breaking the bank.

  1. Trial and Warranty

Brooklinen offers a 365-day trial period and a lifetime warranty on their sheets, showcasing their commitment to customer satisfaction.


  1. Pilling

Some customers have reported pilling issues with Brooklinen sheets, especially the percale variety.

  1. Wrinkles

Brooklinen sheets, particularly the percale and linen varieties, are prone to wrinkles and may require ironing or steaming for a polished look.

The Pros and Cons: L.L. Bean Sheets

LL Bean Sheet
LL Bean Sheet


  1. Durability

L.L. Bean is known for creating long-lasting products, and their sheets are no exception. Crafted from high-quality materials, these sheets are built to last.

  1. Comfort

Many customers rave about the exceptional comfort of L.L. Bean’s sheets, praising their softness and breathability.

  1. Consistency

L.L. Bean has maintained a consistent level of quality over the years, making them a reliable choice for bedding.

  1. Customer Service

L.L. Bean’s excellent customer service ensures that any issues are promptly addressed and resolved.


  1. Limited Variety

L.L. Bean offers a more limited range of materials and colors than Brooklinen, with their most popular option being the 280-thread count percale.

  1. Higher Price Point

L.L. Bean sheets tend to be slightly more expensive than Brooklinen, making them a pricier option for those on a budget.

Frequently Asked Questions

What sheets are similar to Brooklinen?

Some brands that offer similar quality and affordability to Brooklinen include Parachute, Boll & Branch, and Riley Home.

What sheets do 5-star hotels use?

Five-star hotels typically use high-quality sheets made from long-staple cotton with a thread count between 300 and 400. Brands like Frette, Sferra, and Matouk are often found in luxury hotels.

Does Brooklinen make good sheets?

Yes, Brooklinen is known for making high-quality sheets using 100% long-staple cotton. They offer a variety of materials and styles, and many customers rave about their comfort and durability.

Which bed sheets are the best?

The best bed sheets ultimately depend on personal preference, as different materials and weaves suit different needs. However, some popular and highly-regarded options include:
Brooklinen Classic Percale Sheets
L.L. Bean Pima Cotton Percale Sheets
Parachute Linen Sheets
Boll & Branch Signature Hemmed Sheets
Sferra Grande Hotel Sheets

What sheets does Oprah use?

Oprah has mentioned her love for Cozy Earth Bamboo Sheets, which are known for their softness and breathability.

What are the best sheets in the world?

Determining the best sheets in the world is subjective, as individual preferences for material, weave, and thread count vary. However, some luxury brands known for producing exceptional sheets include:
Frette: Known for their Hotel Classic Collection, which graces the beds of numerous high-end hotels.
Sferra: Makers of the Giza 45 Percale and Sateen sheets, crafted from rare Egyptian cotton.
Matouk: Renowned for their 100% Egyptian cotton percale and sateen sheets, such as the Lowell and Nocturne collections.

The Verdict: Brooklinen or L.L. Bean?

When comparing Brooklinen and L.L. Bean sheets, it’s essential to consider your priorities and preferences. If variety and affordability are important to you, Brooklinen might be the better choice, as they offer a broader range of materials, colors, and patterns at a lower price point. 

However, if durability and consistency are your primary concerns, L.L. Bean’s reputation for long-lasting, comfortable sheets may sway your decision in their favor.

Ultimately, both Brooklinen and L.L. Bean produce high-quality sheets that cater to different needs and preferences. 

By taking the time to assess what’s most important to you, you’ll be one step closer to finding the perfect sheets for a blissful night’s sleep. Happy shopping, and sweet dreams!

Clayton S. Johnson

Well, I am Clayton who writes, manages, and does overall stuff for this website. I live somewhere in Stone Mountain, Georgia, and used to have a full-time job. But the pandemic taught me to do more do with my life. So, I quit my job and travel a lot! Since I have tons of time now, I write about all the stuff I have done, used, and have first-hand experiences.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.