Allen Edmonds Vs. Crockett & Jones Shoes (2024)

Footwear is a crucial element of any outfit, and when it comes to high-end, quality shoes, two brands often spark heated debates among aficionados: Allen Edmonds and Crockett & Jones.

These two have set a high standard for men’s footwear, providing timeless style, comfort, and durability.

However, the question remains: which is better, Allen Edmonds or Crockett & Jones shoes? This article will pit these two heavyweights against each other, weighing their pros and cons to help you make an informed decision.

A Brief Comparison Table

FeatureAllen EdmondsCrockett & Jones
Country of Origin/Style InfluenceUnited States/American styleEngland/British style
Manufacturing Process360-degree Goodyear welt270-degree Goodyear welt with a closely trimmed finish
Material QualityHigh-quality leathers, limited high-end optionsSuperior calf leathers and shell cordovan
PriceGenerally more affordableGenerally more expensive
AvailabilityWide retail presence, especially in the USLimited stores, particularly outside Europe
Product RangeExtensive variety of styles and colorsFocused on traditional, timeless styles
Unique ServicesOffers recrafting serviceNo specific unique service beyond general craftsmanship

Unboxing Allen Edmonds: Pros and Cons

Allen Edmonds Shoes
Allen Edmonds Shoes

Established in 1922, Allen Edmonds is a classic American brand revered for its range of quality footwear.

These shoes are known for their meticulous craftsmanship and extensive selection.


  1. Extensive Range: Allen Edmonds offers a wide variety of styles and colors. Whether you’re searching for formal dress shoes, casual loafers, or rugged boots, you’re sure to find a design that suits your style and needs.
  2. Recrafting Service: The Allen Edmonds recrafting service is a unique selling point that gives your shoes a new lease on life. For a reasonable fee, the company restores worn-out shoes to their original glory.
  3. Competitive Pricing: Compared to other luxury shoe brands like Crockett & Jones, Allen Edmonds is generally more affordable, making it a great entry point for those new to luxury footwear.


  1. Inconsistent Quality Control: Some customers have expressed concerns about inconsistent quality in recent years. These issues range from minor aesthetic defects to more serious concerns such as loose stitching.
  2. Limited High-end Options: While Allen Edmonds provides an excellent range, its catalog falls short on truly high-end options, such as shell cordovan models, when compared to brands like Crockett & Jones.

Also Read: Differences Between Ecco And FootJoy Golf Shoes.

Stepping into Crockett & Jones: Pros and Cons

Crockett & Jones, established in 1879 in Northampton, England, is a brand renowned for their craftsmanship and commitment to quality. They create traditional English-style shoes, using only the finest materials.


  1. Superior Craftsmanship: The attention to detail in every Crockett & Jones shoe is truly remarkable. From the selection of premium leathers to the precision in stitching, these shoes are a testament to quality craftsmanship.
  2. Distinct Aesthetics: Crockett & Jones shoes exude a distinct British elegance. Their designs have a unique, timeless appeal that can upgrade any outfit.
  3. High-End Options: Crockett & Jones offers a comprehensive range of high-end options, including luxurious shell cordovan models.


  1. Pricey: The superior quality of Crockett & Jones shoes comes with a hefty price tag, making it inaccessible for some.
  2. Limited Availability: With a smaller physical presence compared to Allen Edmonds, acquiring a pair of Crockett & Jones can be challenging, especially outside Europe.

Key Differences Between Allen Edmonds and Crockett & Jones

When examining Allen Edmonds vs. Crockett & Jones, several key differences emerge that can help determine which brand suits your style and needs better. Let’s delve deeper into these distinctions.

  • Country of Origin and Style Influence
Crockett & Jones Shoes
Crockett & Jones Shoes

One of the primary differences lies in their origin and style influence.

Allen Edmonds, hailing from the United States, leans toward classic American styles.

This means their shoes often feature broader shapes, a robust look, and versatile designs suitable for both dressy and casual outfits.

On the other hand, Crockett & Jones, rooted in Northampton, England, boasts a distinctly British aesthetic.

Their shoes typically have a more streamlined, elegant silhouette that aligns with traditional English footwear.

  • Manufacturing Process and Material Quality

Both brands boast high-quality craftsmanship, but they have different approaches to their manufacturing process. Allen Edmonds uses a 360-degree Goodyear welt construction for many of their shoes, providing durability and the ability to resole, thus extending the shoe’s life.

Crockett & Jones, meanwhile, predominantly utilizes a 270-degree Goodyear welt, with the remainder of the shoe being closely trimmed for a refined finish. This results in a sleeker profile, enhancing the elegant aesthetic of their footwear.

Moreover, Crockett & Jones is known for their use of superior materials, including a range of high-quality calf leathers and luxurious shell cordovan.

  • Price and Accessibility

When it comes to price and accessibility, Allen Edmonds generally offers a more wallet-friendly range. This, combined with a larger retail presence, particularly in the US, makes their shoes more accessible to the average consumer.

Crockett & Jones shoes come with a heftier price tag, reflecting their premium materials and craftsmanship. Also, with fewer stores worldwide, particularly outside Europe, obtaining a pair might require a bit more effort.

  • Product Range and Services

Allen Edmonds shines in its extensive variety of styles and colors. From dress shoes to loafers to boots, they offer something for nearly every occasion. Plus, their unique recrafting service allows you to rejuvenate your worn-out shoes.

Crockett & Jones, while having a slightly narrower range, focuses on traditional, timeless styles. They offer a notable selection of high-end models, including shell cordovan options that are somewhat less common in the Allen Edmonds lineup.

Also Read: Differences Between Carmina And Cobbler Union Shoes.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Why are Crockett & Jones so expensive?

Crockett & Jones shoes are priced high due to their superior materials, meticulous craftsmanship, and the brand’s commitment to quality. They use traditional manufacturing methods, which involve numerous processes executed by skilled artisans. This justifies the higher cost compared to other shoe brands.

Who are Crockett & Jones owned by?

Crockett & Jones remains a family-owned business. The company is currently managed by the fourth generation of the Jones family.

Do Crockett and Jones run large?

Crockett & Jones shoes generally run true to size, but as with any brand, the fit can vary based on the specific model and last shape. It is always recommended to try on different models and sizes to find the perfect fit.

What is the most versatile Allen Edmonds shoe?

One of the most versatile options from Allen Edmonds is the ‘Park Avenue’ Oxford. Its simple yet refined design makes it appropriate for various occasions, from boardroom meetings to weddings.

Wrapping Up

Choosing between Allen Edmonds and Crockett & Jones shoes boils down to personal preference, budget, and needs. If you’re looking for an extensive range and more affordable options, Allen Edmonds could be your brand.

But if British elegance, superior craftsmanship, and high-end options appeal more to you, and if budget isn’t a concern, Crockett & Jones might be the one. Either way, investing in a pair from these brands will elevate your shoe game.

Happy shopping!

Clayton S. Johnson

Well, I am Clayton who writes, manages, and does overall stuff for this website. I live somewhere in Stone Mountain, Georgia, and used to have a full-time job. But the pandemic taught me to do more do with my life. So, I quit my job and travel a lot! Since I have tons of time now, I write about all the stuff I have done, used, and have first-hand experiences.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.