If you are tired of your beach gear becoming a sandy mess or your tote bag flopping over the second you set it down, you should buy either the Bogg Bag or the Yeti Camino today.
Both of these bags have revolutionized how we carry gear for outdoor adventures, whether you are a sports mom or a boat enthusiast.
I have tested both to see which one stands up to the chaos of real life, and I am here to help you decide which investment is right for you.
In this guide, I will compare their durability, ease of cleaning, and overall functionality so you can spend less time packing and more time enjoying.
My Experience: Testing the Limits of the Totes
I have spent months using the Bogg Bag and the Yeti Camino side-by-side during one of the messiest summers on record for my family.
We went from muddy soccer fields on Tuesday nights to sandy beach days every weekend, and I quickly realized that these aren’t just “bags”—they are systems for managing chaos.
When I first unboxed the Bogg Bag, I was struck by how much it really does look like a giant Croc shoe, but once I filled it with four oversized beach towels, three bottles of sunscreen, and a bag of snacks, I stopped caring about the look.
It stood perfectly upright in the soft sand, which is a massive win because I didn’t have to keep one hand on the bag while digging for my sunglasses.
However, after a long day, carrying the Bogg Bag back to the car felt a bit like a workout; it is noticeably heavy when empty, and once you load it up, the straps can sometimes twist and dig into your shoulder if you aren’t careful.
Switching over to the Yeti Camino 35 for our boat trips was a completely different vibe.
The first thing I loved was the deployable dividers; I could keep my wet towels on one side and my dry clothes and keys on the other without them ever touching.
The Yeti feels much more “industrial” and rugged; I actually set it down in a few inches of water on the boat deck, and the waterproof bottom kept everything inside bone-dry.
It also felt much lighter on my shoulder during the walk from the parking lot, and the “CrossBar” handles are much more comfortable than the plastic button straps on the Bogg.
I found myself reaching for the Yeti when I knew things were going to get really rough or wet, but I still loved the Bogg for those casual pool days where I just needed to throw everything in a big bucket and go.
Cleaning both was a dream—I literally lined them up in my driveway and hosed them down after a particularly sandy trip, and they were dry and ready for the next day in under ten minutes.
If you want something that feels fun and holds an incredible amount of gear for a family, the Bogg is great, but if you need something that feels indestructible and keeps you organized, the Yeti is the one I find myself using more often.
Maintenance Tips for Your Rubber Totes
To keep your investment looking brand new for years, you should follow a few simple cleaning and storage rules that apply to both of these heavy-duty bags.
You should hose out your bag after every beach trip: sand can be abrasive over time, so getting it out of the corners of your Bogg or the fabric folds of your Yeti is essential.
Use a mild dish soap and warm water for stubborn stains: if you get sunscreen or soda on the material, a quick scrub with a soft cloth will prevent any permanent discoloration.
Avoid leaving your Bogg Bag in a hot car for extended periods: extreme heat can occasionally cause EVA foam to warp or the straps to lose their shape over time.
Store your Yeti Camino with the dividers folded flat: this helps the bag maintain its shape and prevents the dividers from developing permanent creases.
Check the strap buttons on your Bogg Bag regularly: ensuring they are securely “clicked” in will prevent a handle from popping off while you are carrying a full load.
Always let your bag air dry completely before storing it in a closet: even though they are water-resistant, trapping moisture inside can lead to a musty smell.
You can use a magic eraser on scuff marks: if your Bogg gets a black mark from the pavement, a gentle rub with a magic eraser usually takes it right off.
Keep the Yeti’s HitchPoint grid clear of debris: if you use attachments, make sure the loops aren’t clogged with mud or sand so you can easily swap gear.
Avoid using harsh chemicals like bleach: these can break down the UV-resistant coatings on the material and make the colors fade faster.
If your Bogg Bag straps become twisted, un-click them and reset them: forcing them to stay twisted can put uneven pressure on the plastic buttons and lead to breakage.
Pros and Cons: Bogg Bag Original Large
Pros
- Tip-Proof Design: The wide, treaded bottom keeps the bag upright even on uneven sand or grass.
- Easy Maintenance: The EVA foam material allows you to literally hose it out if it gets sandy or dirty.
- Customizable: You can use the signature holes to attach “Bogg Bits” or charms for a personalized look.
Cons
- Heavy Weight: At 5 lbs empty, it can become quite heavy once fully loaded with family gear.
- No Closure: The open-top design means your items are exposed to the sun or unexpected rain.
Pros and Cons of the Yeti Camino 35 Carryall
Pros:
- Rugged “ThickSkin” shell is nearly indestructible: the material is abrasion-resistant and puncture-resistant, making it perfect for hauling firewood or sharp gear.
- Deployable dividers are a game-changer for organization: you can tuck them away for one big compartment or pop them out to keep muddy boots separate from clean gear.
- The waterproof bottom is a massive advantage on boats: you can set it in a puddle or a wet boat floor and the contents will stay perfectly dry.
- Tested to handle extreme weight: while you probably won’t carry 1,500 pounds, knowing the bag is built for heavy hauling gives you total peace of mind.
- More comfortable carrying options: with both long shoulder straps and short haul handles, it is much easier to transport than the Bogg.
Cons:
- The price point is significantly higher: you are paying a premium for the Yeti brand and the high-tech materials.
- It does not stand as rigidly as the Bogg when empty: while it has some structure, it doesn’t have that “bucket-like” sturdiness of the EVA foam.
- No included pouches for small items: unlike the Bogg, you have to buy your own zippered pouches or organizers if you want to keep tiny items from getting lost.
- Smaller overall capacity compared to the Large Bogg: while the 35 is plenty for most, it doesn’t quite match the sheer “throw-it-all-in” volume of its competitor.
Also Read: My Experience With Lucshy Travel Bag
Bogg Bag Vs. Other Brands
- Bogg Bag Vs. Simply Southern
Simply Southern offers a tote that is almost a mirror image of the Bogg Bag, right down to the material and the hole pattern.
The main difference I have found is that Simply Southern often uses patterned straps or more vibrant, preppy designs that appeal to a different aesthetic.
If you are looking for the Bogg “look” but want to save about twenty dollars, Simply Southern is the most comparable alternative on the market.
- Bogg Bag Vs. Simple Modern Getaway
The Simple Modern version is much lighter than the Bogg and features hinged straps that fold down neatly for easier access.
I think the Simple Modern is a better choice for someone who wants a “lifestyle” bag for the gym or grocery store, as it looks a bit less like a piece of beach equipment.
However, it isn’t quite as thick as the Bogg, so it might not survive a decade of heavy-duty beach abuse in the same way.
- Yeti Camino Vs. L.L. Bean Boat and Tote
The L.L. Bean is the classic canvas standard, but it lacks the “hose-ability” that makes the Yeti so popular.
If you get the L.L. Bean wet or sandy, you are looking at a long drying process and potential stains, whereas the Yeti is ready to go again in minutes.
The Yeti is for the person who wants the classic tote shape but needs modern, high-tech materials that can survive a hose-down.
- Yeti Camino Vs. Hydro Flask 35L Day Escape
Hydro Flask makes a great tote, but theirs is more focused on being a “soft cooler” with insulation.
The Yeti Camino is a “carryall,” meaning it isn’t insulated, but it is much tougher and better for hauling gear like boots, wet towels, or firewood.
If your primary goal is keeping drinks cold, go with the Hydro Flask; if your goal is hauling literally anything else, the Yeti wins.
- Bogg Bag Vs. Costco Beachcomber Bag
The Costco version is often called the “Beachcomber Bag” and usually sells for about half the price of a name-brand Bogg.
It has the same tip-proof design and easy-to-clean material, though it sometimes lacks the high-end finish or the variety of color options.
If you are lucky enough to find it in stock at your local warehouse, it is an incredible value for anyone on a budget.
Also Read: Comparison Of Bogg Bag Vs. Simple Modern
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
It is popular because it combines Yeti’s legendary durability with a versatile design that is waterproof, nearly indestructible, and easy to clean.
The Bogg Bag creator (Twenty-Six Designs) has filed lawsuits against several companies for “trade dress infringement,” alleging they copied the bag’s unique design and hole pattern.
At Costco, the similar rubberized tote is typically sold under the name “Beachcomber Bag.”
Final Thoughts
If you want the most durable, easy-to-clean tote for your family’s summer adventures, you should buy either the Bogg Bag or the Yeti Camino today.
I have found that the Bogg is perfect for those who need maximum space and a fun look, while the Yeti is the superior choice for rugged, organized hauling.
Both will save you from the headache of ruined canvas bags and sandy car trunks, making your outings much more enjoyable.
You deserve a bag that works as hard as you do, and either of these picks will serve you faithfully for years to come.
I am confident that once you switch to a hosed-off rubber tote, you will never go back to a traditional beach bag again.
